Fluid

Genderwitched

Pulled towards a gender you cannot confirm is yours.

  • One of twenty-three Fluid identities
  • No settled flag
  • 10 min read
A character dancing under a violet sky

What it is

There is a gender that keeps catching your eye. You read about it. You imagine being addressed as it. Then you stop, because you can't honestly say it's yours.

That gap — pulled towards something, unable to confirm it — is what this word was made for. The original definition, posted in 2015: you are intrigued or entranced by the idea of a particular gender, but are not certain you're actually experiencing it.

Be warned about what this word is. It arrived in a pride-flag archive in August 2015 with a flag and a single sentence attached. Almost nobody has written about living it.

Keep reading

Search it today and you mostly find flag catalogues and hostile lists counting up how many genders people have supposedly invented. That is a real thing you will run into, and it is worth knowing before you go looking.

So this page describes the experience the definition points at. It can't describe a community, because there isn't a documented one. Nobody can tell you what genderwitched people are like — including this page.

People also disagree on the meaning. Some read it as: drawn to a gender you are not. Others, following the original wording, read it as: drawn to a gender and genuinely unsure. Those are different states, and the word gets used for both.

What it isn't is a claim. That's the point of it. It's a word for the middle of the sentence, not the end.

Pronouns

No pronoun set comes with this word. People who use it use everything — she, he, they, neopronouns, or the ones they were handed at birth.

One pattern does turn up. Some people hold off changing their pronouns for years, because changing them feels like announcing something they can't yet prove.

If that's you: you can test a set privately. Trying a pronoun is not a declaration, and nobody has to hear it.

Does this sound like you?

You've read the same definition page more times than you'd admit, and never once thought 'that's me' — only 'what if'.
You save the posts. You don't repost them.
You've said the name and the pronouns out loud when nobody was home, just to hear how they sit.
Someone assumed you were that gender once. You felt caught out, then quietly pleased, then guilty about being pleased.
You've written the message telling someone, and deleted it — not out of fear, but because you couldn't stand behind the claim.
You keep waiting for the moment of certainty that would settle it. It hasn't come.
You feel like a visitor in a community you keep going back to.
You'd feel like a fraud taking the word. You'd also feel like you were lying if you said it was nothing.

Take the test

Twenty questions, about four minutes, nothing leaves your phone. It suggests. You decide.

Take the test

An ordinary day

Nothing about the day announces itself. You get up, get dressed, and the clothes are fine. They're just clothes.

Then something small lands. A character in the thing you're watching. A stranger at the counter. The word used for someone else, and the small pull under your ribs when you hear it.

You look it up again. The same page you've already read. You get to the bottom and you still can't say yes.

At some point there's a form. You tick the box you always tick, because the honest answer isn't listed and "I don't know" isn't either.

In the evening the feed hands you more of it, because you keep pausing on it. That's not a sign. That's an algorithm.

By midnight you've either decided it's nothing, or decided you'll think about it tomorrow. Tomorrow it's still there.

What people get wrong

“You're just an ally who wants to be included.”
The definition is about not being sure. Being unsure isn't the same as pretending, and a word that means 'I don't know' is a strange thing to accuse someone of using as a backdoor.
“If it were really your gender, you'd know.”
Plenty of people describe years of not knowing before anything settled. Plenty never got a clean moment of knowing at all. Certainty is not the entry fee it gets sold as.
“This is just questioning with a costume on.”
Partly fair, and some people use it as exactly that. The distinction others draw: questioning implies you're on the way to an answer. This one doesn't promise you'll arrive.
“It's a made-up internet word.”
It was coined online in 2015. That's true, and not much of an insult — most gender words were coined by someone, somewhere. The fair warning is different: it's rare, and most people you meet won't have heard it.
“You're just experiencing gender envy.”
Related, not the same. Envy points at a person and what they have. This points at a gender and asks whether it belongs to you.

How it actually plays out

Love

The awkward part isn't rejection. It's "so what are you" from someone kind who genuinely wants to get it right.

You can say: there's a gender I keep circling, and I don't know yet. Most decent people can hold that. The ones who push for a category anyway are telling you something useful about themselves.

If you're with someone long-term, this can be harder than a clean answer would be. Partners often cope well with change. They cope worse with unresolved, because they can't tell what they're preparing for.

Say the timeline out loud: I may not resolve this. That's the honest offer, and it's better made early than at year six.

If you're not with anyone, plenty of people sit in this alone. It isn't a queue you're stuck in.

Desire

There's one confusion this word runs into constantly. Being drawn to a gender and wanting to be one can feel identical from the inside, especially in fantasy.

Watch where the attention goes. If you're picturing the person, that's attraction. If you're picturing being looked at as that gender, or being called it in bed, that's the other thing. It can be both at once.

Some people find the pull shows up mainly here — in fantasy, in what they want said to them — and nowhere else in the day. That's still information, even if it only ever appears in the dark.

Others find their sex life is completely untouched by any of this. That's ordinary too, and it doesn't rule you out of anything.

The body

Body feelings here tend to be quiet and unconfirmed. Not "this is wrong". More "I wonder".

That's a difficult place to make medical decisions from, and it's fair to say so plainly. Most systems want a settled story before they'll do anything, and you don't have one to give them.

Reversible things exist for exactly this reason. Hair, clothes, voice practice, binding, how people address you. You're allowed to test something without it being a verdict.

And plenty of people with this feeling have no distress about their body at all. The pull is about being seen and named, not about flesh. That doesn't make it smaller.

Work

Work is mostly paperwork and half-second decisions. The pronoun field in the signature. The form with two boxes. Someone assuming, and you choosing whether to correct them before the moment passes.

You don't owe your workplace a resolved answer. "Genderwitched" is also not a word that will survive an HR conversation intact.

If you need something to say, a broad word does the job — nonbinary, questioning, or nothing. Using a simpler word in public isn't dishonesty. It's a different audience.

If you're somewhere it isn't safe to say anything, saying nothing is a decision. It isn't cowardice and it isn't a failure.

Family

Families want a finished sentence. "So which is it" is the question, and you don't have the thing it's asking for.

You can tell them there's something you're working out, and you'll say more when there's more. Some will take that. Some will hear "phase" — and being called a phase while you're genuinely unsure stings in a specific way, because part of you is afraid they're right.

In many families and many languages there's no word for this at all. You may end up describing a feeling rather than naming an identity. That's harder, and often more honest anyway.

You are not required to tell them. Not now, not ever, not if it would cost you your home.

Coming out

Coming out usually means announcing a conclusion. You don't have one. That makes this genuinely awkward rather than only frightening.

Three options that actually work. Tell nobody, and keep it yours. Tell one safe person the real thing — that you're pulled towards something and can't tell yet. Or use a wider word in public and keep the precise one private.

If you do use the word itself, expect to explain it. There's no encyclopaedia entry to send. Have one sentence ready: there's a gender I keep being drawn to, and I can't tell yet whether it's mine.

Safety comes before precision, every time. In some homes, some jobs and some countries, the correct move is to say nothing at all.

Nearby identities

The distinction is the useful part. Names without a link don’t have a page yet.

Demigirl / demiboy

A partial but confirmed connection to a gender. Genderwitched confirms nothing. That's the whole distinction.

Demigirl → · Demiboy →
Gender envy

A feeling, not an identity, and cis and trans people both get it. Envy is about wanting what someone else has. This is about a gender that might turn out to be yours.

Intricargender

A near-neighbour from the same mid-2010s coining scene, about being fascinated by a gender. The two get used interchangeably and nobody has settled the line between them.

Genderwitch

A separate word, coined later, about witchcraft and the witch as a gender. Constantly mixed up with this one because of the spelling. Unrelated in meaning.

Aporagender / maverique

A distinct nonbinary gender that is definite and stable. Roughly the opposite of the state described here.

Aporagender → · Maverique →

It might not be you if…

  • You already know, and what's stopping you is fear of saying it. That's a different problem, and a far more common one.
  • Your gender is settled and the difficulty is other people refusing to accept it.
  • You move between genders you can name. That's fluid, and it has better-documented words waiting for you.
  • You're clear that you want to be that gender. Wanting it plainly is closer to an ordinary trans experience than to this.
  • The pull is entirely about clothes, hair and aesthetics, with no gender question sitting underneath it.
  • What draws you is the community rather than the gender itself.
  • You want a label that explains you to a stranger in four words. This one needs a paragraph and a link.

On the hard days

The bad nights have a particular shape. Not grief. Suspicion.

The fear that you invented the whole thing. That you're a tourist. That you're taking up room belonging to people who are sure.

Some people will say that to you outright, and a few of them will be inside the community. It lands hard because it's the same sentence you've already said to yourself at 3am.

Here's the part worth keeping. Not knowing is a real state to be in. It isn't a task you're failing to finish, and nobody is holding a deadline over you.

If the pull is still there in a year, it's still there. If it fades, nothing was wasted — you looked, and you found out. Both of those are proper endings.

And if the unsureness itself is making you unwell — not thinking, but sleepless, not eating, unable to function — take that to someone. Not because your gender is a problem, but because you shouldn't have to carry it on your own.

Questions people ask

What does genderwitched mean?

The original 2015 definition: you're intrigued or entranced by the idea of a particular gender, but aren't certain you're actually experiencing it. Note that two readings circulate — one where you're drawn to a gender you're definitely not, and one where you're drawn to it and genuinely don't know. The original wording supports the second. The word gets used for both.

Is genderwitched just questioning with extra steps?

Honestly, they overlap heavily, and some people use them for the same thing. The line others draw is that questioning suggests you're heading somewhere — a stage with an exit. This word doesn't promise an answer is coming. If 'questioning' describes you and is easier to say out loud, there's no prize for using the rarer word.

Is genderwitched a real identity or a made-up internet word?

Both, in a sense. It was coined online in 2015 and posted with a flag and one sentence. Very few people use it and almost nobody has written about living it, so there's no body of shared experience behind it. The feeling it names is real and common. The word for it is small and thinly documented. Those are two separate facts, and it's worth holding both.

Can I call myself genderwitched if I turn out to be cis?

Yes. The word describes not being sure, so it can't be invalidated by the answer arriving later. If you look into it for two years and conclude you're cis, you weren't lying — you were looking. Some people also find the fascination stays and never resolves into anything, and they keep the word for that. Nothing is owed back.

Kai Moss Editor (pen name)

Last updated · How these pages are written and checked

No flag is shown because none is settled. Text: written from how people who use the word Genderwitched describe it.

This is not a clinical instrument, not a diagnosis, and not evidence of anything about anyone. It describes experiences so you can recognise your own — or rule them out.