Take the test
Expression

Soft butch

Butch with the edges rounded — less tough, more mixing, still butch. Not a lower rank; a different setting.

  • A way of presenting, not an identity
  • No settled flag
  • 4 min read

A way of presenting, not a gender identity. Soft butch is a way of presenting — a gentler butch style — not a gender identity in itself.

A shorter entry: the essentials, written to the same standard. The fuller guides are on the main identities.

What it is

Soft butch is butch turned down a notch, or turned sideways. The masculinity is still load-bearing — the shirts, the stance, the way you are clocked across a room — but it comes without the toughness, or with feminine details mixed in. The LGBTQIA+ Wiki's Butch entry describes a soft butch as a butch who does not act very tough, or is all round a softer type of person, and adds the line this page lives by: that does not make them more feminine or less of a butch than any other butch.

Wikipedia files it with its cousins. Soft butch, stem, futch and chapstick lesbian, its Butch and femme page says, are emerging terms for women who have characteristics of both butch and femme. That is the honest map: a middle ground with several names, drawn by people who got tired of being asked which side they were on.

What it is not: a gender identity. Butch, for some, is a gender in its own right; soft butch is almost always a description of how the butch is carried. It is not quite futch either — futch usually means a real blend that could be read either way, where soft butch keeps the butch and softens it. And it is not a probationary butch waiting to harden up.

Pronouns

She/her most often, with they/them and he/him in the mix, as for butch generally. The "soft" says nothing about pronouns. Ask.

Does this sound like you?

Men's shirt, and you will cry at the film. Both were true before you had the word.
Butch women have told you that you are not really butch. Femmes have told you that you obviously are. You have stopped keeping score.
You have been the safe walk home, and you have also been the one who needed one.
Your haircut is short. Your hands are not rough. You are fine with both.
You have worn one feminine thing to a wedding — a necklace, a bit of colour — and enjoyed the double-take more than the thing itself.
Handsome still lands harder than pretty. You would just also like to be held sometimes.
You went through a stretch of trying to be tougher than you are, to earn the word. It did not take, and the word stayed anyway.

Nearby identities

The distinction is the useful part.

Butch

The parent. Same masculinity, same lineage. Soft butch is a setting on it — and the wiki is explicit that softer is not lesser.

Compare Soft butch and Butch →
Futch

The honest blend. Futch sits at the centre, femme and butch at once, and could be read either way. Soft butch stays on the butch side with the edges rounded.

Compare Soft butch and Futch →
Stone butch

Not a level of butchness — a fact about touch, giving rather than receiving. You can be soft and stone, or hard and not.

Compare Soft butch and Stone butch →
Femme

The counterpart on the feminine side. Soft butch borrows a detail or two from femme without moving house.

Compare Soft butch and Femme →
Masc

The plain description of a masculine look, without the butch lineage. Some soft butches say masc in mixed company because it needs less explaining.

Compare Soft butch and Masc →

It might not be you if…

  • You are masculine in the way that has no charge to it — pockets, practicality, done. That is masc, or just clothes.
  • You are genuinely in the middle and it matters to you that people cannot tell. Futch is the word made for that.
  • You want to be a man, read as one everywhere, permanently. Soft butch is not a stop on that road; transmasculine and trans man are the pages.
  • You want this label because "butch" felt like too much to claim. Butch does not require an audition; the wiki says as much.

Questions people ask

Is soft butch less butch than butch?

No. The LGBTQIA+ Wiki's Butch entry says a soft butch is not more feminine or less of a butch than any other type. It is a description of manner, not a rank.

What's the difference between soft butch and futch?

Futch is a blend that could go either way — Wikipedia lists it, with soft butch and stem, among the terms for women with characteristics of both butch and femme. Soft butch keeps butch as the base and softens it. In practice the two overlap and people pick the one that sounds like them.

Can non-binary people be soft butch?

Yes, on the same terms as butch. The wiki notes butch is used by non-binary people as well as women. Soft butch inherits that.

Guide · 12 min readGender Expression vs Gender Identity: The Difference

One is what you are. The other is what people can see. They get confused for each other constantly, by strangers, by families, by…

Guide · 10 min readGender expression: the wardrobe, the workplace and the safety maths

Gender expression is the part of gender other people can see, and it is the only part that costs money, draws comments and depends on the…

Kai Moss Editor (pen name)

Last updated · How these pages are written and checked

No flag is shown because none is settled. Text: written from how people who use the word Soft butch describe it.

Sources:

  • Butch — LGBTQIA+ Wiki (Soft Butch section) — Fetched. The Other Terms section defines soft butch as a butch who does not act very tough or is a softer type of person, not more feminine or less of a butch; also notes a soft butch flag of unknown date. lgbtqia.wiki has no standalone Soft_butch page (404).
  • Butch and femme — Wikipedia — Fetched. Lists soft butch, stem, futch and chapstick lesbian as emerging terms for women with characteristics of both butch and femme; defines stone butch.

This is not a clinical instrument, not a diagnosis, and not evidence of anything about anyone. It describes experiences so you can recognise your own — or rule them out.